Skip to main content

Offenders with Common Mental Health Problems: a multi-dimensional and multi-perspective study

The aim of this project is to provide the first detailed examination of how offenders’ narratives of their distress and well-being differs from the definitions used by the international classifications of mental disorders as well as practitioners’ own definitions of mental disorders; other contributory factors to distress and well being such as previous trauma, goals and ambitions will be explored.

How people understand the mental health and care or ‘perceive’it can have an affect on their health-seeking behavior. The culture in which people live provides the context within which these perceptions are acquired. Offenders and practitioners are likely to come from different social backgrounds. Social theorist, Pierre Bourdieu argued that an individual’s perception of social phenomena is affected by their position in society; particularly their accumulation of power, education and money. Using Bourdieu’s theory one can explore differences in perceptions of mental illness between offenders and practitioners and compare these with internationally recognised classifications of mental disorders (DSM-IV, ICD-10). These differences in perceptions can cause difficulties in providing mental healthcare, particularly for hard-to-reach groups such as offenders.

Adult offenders, serving prison or community sentences, are a population with increased prevalence, as defined by internationally recognised classifications (ICD-10, DSM-IV), of common (anxiety and depression) and serious mental disorders (bipolar disorder, personality disorders) when compared to general population. In addition, a large percentage of this population misuses substances, (drug and alcohol) suffers from more than one condition and faces severe social problems (low income, housing problems). The increased prevalence of social and psychological problems of this population coupled with the fear of stigma of mental illness and distrust towards health professionals make access and continuity of care a difficult task.

The use and integration of the biopsychosocial model by practitioners wanting to consider the whole person has considerably increased. This model, that is now being extended to incorporate an understanding of individuals’ internal and external resources or strenghts, goals and choices about treatment, has been subjected to little research.

The proposed research methodology is based on a mixed-methods research approach. It will be primarily qualitative with embedded contextual quantitative analysis. Furthermore, it will include visits to community based services, a literature review, initial screening, identification and categorisation of male adult offenders in probation and prison (if operational factors allow), followed by in-depth study of a purposively sampled sub-set of participants, observations of clinical encounters integrating in-depth interviews of both offenders and practitioners involved in their care.


This study will describe offenders and practitioners’ perceptions regarding their mental health problems and the care provided; how components of the biopsychosocial model of care are being used and finally the meaning and acceptability of these components. This description should inform the development of care for offenders.

Upcoming Events

Sep
11

Searching and Review Clinic

Room 2.17, South Cloisters, St Lukes Campus, University of Exeter

These clinics have been set up to help the PenCLAHRC Evidence Synthesis Team to manage and respond...
More information

Sep
27

Searching and Review Clinic

Room N14, ITTC Building, Plymouth

These clinics have been set up to help the PenCLAHRC Evidence Synthesis Team to manage and respond...
More information

Calendar

News

Job opportunity - PenCLAHRC Research Fellow

02 August 2018

The University of Plymouth Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry are looking to recruit a Research Fellow within...
Read more

Professor Ken Stein appointed Director of the NIHR Systematic Reviews Programme

22 July 2018

PenCLAHRC’s Deputy Director, Professor Ken Stein, has been appointed as Programme Director for the NIHR Systematic Reviews (SR)...
Read more

Celebrating positives in the classroom may improve child behaviour and mental health

18 July 2018

Training teachers to focus their attention on positive conduct, and to avoid jumping to correct...
Read more

News

Research Projects

Improving Continence

Theme: Evidence for Policy and Practice

What is the available evidence for interventions relating to improving continence for children and young...
Read more

UNTEST

Theme: Diagnostics & Stratified Medicine

How can we help GPs make better use of thyroid function tests?
Read more

Research Projects